Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

Discover Porter Island Seafood Restaurant in Crawfordville, FL, offering delicious seafood favorites like crab cakes, blackened shrimp, mahi mahi, and more. Enjoy mouthwatering cheese grits, hush puppies, and prime rib sandwiches in a welcoming setting. Call +1 850-745-8840 for your seafood feast!

Welcome to Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

Experience the finest dining

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant brings the essence of coastal cuisine to Crawfordville, Florida. Located at 4518 Crawfordville Hwy, this bustling eatery offers an inviting atmosphere for seafood lovers. The menu showcases an array of fresh dishes, with standout items like crab cakes, blackened shrimp, and the mouthwatering prime rib sandwich. Relish the comfort of homemade cheese grits as you explore flavors that echo the Gulf Coast. Guests cherish the relaxed vibe, whether enjoying a casual family dinner or a special occasion. With peak times on Friday evenings, reservations are recommended to secure a table. Experience the culinary treasure of Porter Island Seafood Restaurant, where each bite brings a taste of the sea right to your plate.

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant boasts a diverse menu with 89 unique dishes. This local gem excels in both seafood and traditional American fare, making it suitable for all palates. Start with tasty appetizers like homemade cheese sticks or spicy buffalo shrimp. The salad options include a refreshing ahi tuna salad and hearty chicken salad. For those craving heartier meals, the main menu features platters like the captain’s platter and the home made crab cakes.

A family-friendly ambiance enhances the dining experience.

There’s a dedicated kids menu, ensuring that everyone finds something to enjoy. Guests appreciate the cozy interior adorned with nautical themes, providing a perfect backdrop for seafood feasts. The restaurant also prides itself on great customer service, with friendly staff ready to help navigate the extensive menu.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

4518 Crawfordville Hwy, Crawfordville, FL 32327, United States

Phone

+1 850-745-8840

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant
Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant has become a cornerstone of Crawfordville’s dining landscape. Since opening its doors, it has earned a reputation for serving some of the best seafood in the area. The owners prioritize sourcing fresh ingredients to create high-quality dishes that reflect regional flavors. This commitment to quality shines through in every aspect, from the friendly service to the well-presented plates.

The extensive menu appeals to a wide range of preferences, featuring everything from scrumptious starters to delectable desserts. Guests regularly rave about the crab claws and the deep-fried catfish, often regarded as must-tries for first-time visitors. Different specials often rotate throughout the week, giving local patrons a reason to stop by regularly. The family atmosphere ensures that families can gather and celebrate milestones over a feast of fresh seafood and tasty sides.

Notably, Friday evenings bring a vibrant crowd as diners flock to the restaurant, eager to indulge. This peak time makes it vital to plan ahead if dining during these busy hours. Many regulars swear by the lunch specials available on weekends and the comforting breakfast options offered every morning. The confluence of flavors, quality service, and a welcoming ambiance sets Porter Island apart in a busy town.

Crawfordville residents often mention meeting friends and family here as part of their local traditions. The restaurant fills with laughter and conversation, creating a sense of community that goes beyond just dining. Porter Island Seafood Restaurant stands not only as a place to eat but as a gathering spot for locals, fostering connections and creating memories over plates of seafood delights.

Porter Island Seafood Restaurant

The exterior of Porter Island Seafood Restaurant captures the charm of a coastal eatery with its warm colors and nautical theme. Located conveniently along Crawfordville Hwy, it stands out with a welcoming sign that invites diners to experience local flavors. Outdoor seating options allow guests to enjoy the pleasant Florida weather while relishing their meals.

The vibe is casual and relaxed, perfect for families and friends alike.

Laughter often fills the air as friends share plates and stories, making it a popular gathering spot. The combination of great food and a comfortable atmosphere establishes it as a favorite destination for both locals and visitors seeking authentic seafood.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-6 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Our Birthday outing for mom's birthday. Was exceptional. My steak was cooked to perfection, seasoned wonderfully. My husband ordered captain seafood platter. Seafood was cooked perfectly, great portions. Mom ordered hamburger steak dinner. She said it was delicious. Our server Jessica made sure our tea glasses stay filled. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

V
Valerie P.

With the way I currently have to eat I had to change a few things and they were quick to accommodate my requests. And the food is amazing. Also the staff is very friendly.

A
Alicia B.

What a cute little place! They take a lot of pride in keeping it very tidy and the service is very friendly. I had a large and delicious breakfast (standard fare). My wife enjoyed her seafood and sausage omelette. The coffee was hot and rich. If we lived closer, it would be our go to place for breakfast.

R
Robin M.

I had the Kids Shrimp, so good! My husband got the special, which was Flounder & Shrimp with 2 sides. I'm expecting some small filets to come out. I was shocked to see a humongous fish on that plate, but very tasty!! Service was excellent!!

S
Shelly H.

The service was great. Everyone was friendly. The food tasted great. My wife is very picky and she also loved her plate. Perfectly cooked. I had the Mahi Mahi with scallops and OMG. It was just awesome. I really recommend it. Margie is excellent A+.

D
David L.

We were traveling the coastline from Panama City Beach down. In from Pennsylvania. We stopped here due to other reviews. Marisa was our server and she was friendly and fantastic. Our food was excellent and the homemade garlic butter was ridiculous. My husband went with the daily special Buffalo Shrimp Po' Boy sandwich with fries and I had the catfish lunch with sweet potato fries and hush puppies and added cole slaw. Such a good stop! Added unsweetened teas and was only $24 plus tax and tip. Highly recommend!

J
Julie R.